Monday, March 26, 2012

Clay Austin of 3/25/2012

Clay,

Thanks so much.  I ordered the kit.

Here is what I have:

John Ellison Austin’s

Parents are: Ellison Woodrow Austin and Kathrine Bell

Grandparents are: Jacob Ellison Austin and Jennie Long

Great-grandparents are: Unknown Stultz man and Sara/Sallie Austin

2nd ggparents are: William Austin and Lucinda Lloyd (parents of Sara/Sallie and of Joseph Calvin Austin, Sr.)


Your tree:

Grandparents: Joseph Calvin Austin, Sr. and Annie Purnell

Great-grandparents: William Austin and Lucinda Lloyd

So Sara/Sallie is a sister of your Joseph Calvin Sr.  She is the mother of Jacob Ellison Austin (not a sister to him), in all likelihood. Therefore Jacob Ellison was a nephew of Joseph Calvin Sr. instead of a brother.

This being correct that makes John Ellison Austin your 2nd cousin once removed instead of your 2nd cousin as was thought before John Ellison took the Y-DNA test last year.

Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Letter to clay again... 3/14/2012

Clay,

I have attached a PDF that was written by Alvy Ray Smith, a Fellow in the American Genealogical Society and a Riggs expert. He summarizes the need for additional Y-DNA samples to answer  the question “Who is the Riggs man who is the progenitor of the Austin family headed by Archibald Austin, Sr.?”  On the 2nd page he points out the importance of obtaining the Y-DNA from a descendant of Arch Jr., brother of Clisbe Sr.  That man is you.

If you take the test and match the Edwardian Riggs Y-DNA model, then you will prove:

1.      Archibald Austin, Sr. is a Riggs, genetically.

2.      Clisbe Riggs is not the progenitor (as on page 2 of Alvy discussion) since he was 2 years old when Arch Sr. was born.

3.      Your Y-DNA will potentially answer the question of Edward Riggs’ being the progenitor.
 

If you take the test and match the Austin Y-DNA model (from Southside VA), then you will prove:

4.      Clisbe Austin, Sr. is not a son of Archibald Austin, Sr.

5.      Archibald Austin Sr. was likely a son of Joseph Austin of Southside VA.


If you take the test and match neither the Riggs nor the Austin model (as is the case of your cousin John), then you will prove:

6.      Another total surprise which will need to be explained.

7.      My luck is unbelievably bad… and I’ll be looking for another descendant of Archibald Austin, Jr. to answer my Riggs question.


Of course you know that I’m betting that you will turn out to be a Riggs, genetically. I’ve been wrong before. Wouldn’t mind being wrong again. Just would like very much to know the answer. I’ve been working on this puzzle for about 1-1/2 years now. My co-author of the story of Wealthy Pruett and a cousin of yours, Nancy Austin Fatheree, has been working on this with me constantly for the 1-1/2 years also. She wants the answer as badly as I do.

 I thought you might like the see the Y-DNA certificates of a couple of men mentioned in Alvy’s discussion. I have attached the certificates of Robert Carter Austin, Jr. and Horace Lester Riggs, III.

Is there any way for me to convince you to participate?


John Clinard

9 or 10, there is a difference

Here is the Clay connection which probably by-passes the problem with John Ellison Austin.  This will tell us about the markers for Arch Sr., if I can get him to donate his Y-DNA.  Got any persuasive words?


Clay7 Austin (Joseph C. Jr.6, Joseph C Sr.5, William4, Archibald Jr.3, Arch Sr.2 Austin, Edward Riggs1).  Clay may be either a 9 or 10 at marker 47. I’m convinced that if Clay is a 9, then Arch Sr. is a 9; and if a 10, then Arch Sr. is a 10.  Is this right?

This will tell us 9 or 10 at marker 47 for Arch Sr.  Help me out here, please.  This seems easy; but it’s not easy to me.

If Arch Sr. is a 9, as you expect, then will that indicate/prove that the mutation to 9 occurred in Arch Sr. prior to his having sons Clisbe Sr. and Arch Jr.? Or will it prove he is not a son of Edward, who is surely a 10? Or, is it really that we can’t differentiate between these two distinctly different possibilities? Are the probabilities of the two quite different?

If Arch Sr. is a 10, then what would be proven? Will that prove that the mutation to 9 occurred in Clisbe Sr. prior to his having children?... cause we know Clisbe Sr. is a 9.
____________
Alvy answer:
 
If Clay7 (using your nomenclature) has a 9 at marker 47, then almost certainly Arch2 Sr. does too.

If Clay7 has a 10 there then we just don’t know whether Arch2 Sr. has a 9 or a 10 and would have to say it that way. In that case, it would be POSSIBLE (but not proved) that the 10 came from Edward5 and was (I’m just hypothesizing here) the same 10 passed down to Horace and Roy. That’s consistent story, but unfortunately unproved. It just doesn’t DISPROVE it, which is good.

There is no reason for two sons to have exactly the same YDNA as the father. A mutation has to happen somewhere, typically in a procreative event.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Letter to CLAY of3/8/12

153 Chuniloti Way

Loudon, TN

March 8, 2012

Clay Austin

291 Tipton LN

Blountville, TN 37617

Dear Clay,

Thought you might not be seeing all your e-mail, so I’m sending this to you in USPS. I’m hoping you are still considering participating in the Austin-Riggs Y-DNA study. The e-mails I have attached explain, as best I can, why it is important to Austin-Riggs family members and to me that you become a Y-DNA donor. You are the answer, about the only one available, as far as I can determine, for answering the two questions:
Was Archibald Austin, Jr. genetically from the Austin family or the Riggs family?

Who is the father of Archibald Austin, Sr.?

Sincerely,

John Clinard    865-607-9191

Monday, February 20, 2012

Sivert Stuff

Elanor Conka, born 1896 in Almas, Austria-Hungary.  Her “race” was listed as Croatian. Her nativity was listed as Hungary with last town of Almas.

I attached a picture of the ship. It’s called the CARPATHIA I think.
In 1912, the Carpathia arrived at the scene, after working her way through dangerous ice fields, and took on 705 survivors of the disaster from Titanic's lifeboats.

How about that.  Your grandmother missed it by only 2 years.
_________________
Wikipedia says “Croatia was in personal union with Hungary from 1102. Croat communities were spread mostly in the western and southern part of the country and along the Danube, including Budapest.” So, she likely was of Croat ethnicity.
Elanor Conka, born 1896 in Almas, Austria-Hungary.  Her “race” was listed as Croatian. Her nativity was listed as Hungary with last town of Almas.
I attached a picture of the ship. It’s called the CARPATHIA I think.
In 1912, the Carpathia arrived at the scene, after working her way through dangerous ice fields, and took on 705 survivors of the disaster from Titanic's lifeboats.
How about that.  Your grandmother missed it by only 2 years.
JAC




First letter to Clay Austin

Clay, 
Below I’ll try to explain what we talked about last night. My wife Lillian Austin Clinard is your 4th cousin:

Lillian7 Austin (Frank Smith6, Clyde B.5, Clisbe, Jr.4, Clisbe, Sr.3, Arch Sr.2 Austin, Edward Riggs1)

Clay7 Austin (Joseph C. Jr.6, Joseph C Sr.5, William4, Archibald Jr.3, Arch Sr.2 Austin, Edward Riggs1).  
The most recent common ancestor (MRCA) for Lil and you is Archibald Austin, Sr. He is 3rd great-grandfather to both of you. Thus, you and Lil are 4th cousins. Of course what I’m trying to prove through Y-DNA is the connection all the way back to Edward Riggs (1720-1820), probably a 4th ggfather to Lil and you.

I started my study about 18 months ago when I convinced Robert Austin, Lil’s 1st cousin, to take the Y-DNA test to prove that the father of Archibald, Sr. was Joseph Austin (1730-1811) of Southside VA. Y-DNA is useful, accurate, and inexpensive.  It follows the father’s-father’s-father’s side of the family and remains basically unchanged from generation to generation.  Since Lil has no Y-DNA (a female), it was necessary to use her male 1st cousin for the proof. The results for Robert were surprising. Instead of proving Joseph was the father of Arch, I proved that Robert was from the Riggs family with the following likely ancestry:

Robert7 Austin (Robert, Sr.6, Clyde B.5, Clisbe, Jr.4, Clisbe, Sr.3, Arch Sr.2 Austin, Edward Riggs1)

Of course the proof to the specific Riggs man, Edward Riggs (1720-1820), has taken me the better part of 18 months, so far, and I am still missing a piece of the proof,  that which you could provide.  I will discuss this later, below. I will also send you a CD with an extensive write-up.  It’s called the “Story of Wealthy Pruett”, the known mother of Archibald (Pruett) Austin, Sr.  Nancy Austin Fatheree, also a cousin of yours from TX, wrote this story with me.

At first I thought I must be wrong about Robert, so I convinced another of Lil’s 1st cousins to take the test. Clyde Austin’s results were identical to Robert Austin’s.

Clyde7 Austin (Clyde, Jr.6, Clyde B.5, Clisbe, Jr.4, Clisbe, Sr.3, Arch Sr.2 Austin, Edward Riggs1)
Clyde and Robert have a MRCA of Clyde B. Austin, their grandfather. Thus at this point I had proven that Clyde B was from the Riggs family. That’s about all the Y-DNA had done so far.

Then with the help of Nancy Austin Fatheree, I was able to get the Y-DNA from William Luther Austin.

William Luther8 Austin (William Brinks7, William Thompson6, Robert White5, William Thompson4, Clisbe Sr.3, Archibald Sr2, Edward Riggs1)
The Y-DNA of William matched Robert and Clyde perfectly. Clyde and Robert and William Luther have a MRCA of Clisbe Austin, Sr. Thus at this point I/we had proven that Clisbe Sr. was from the Riggs family.
To get to the next level back in time, I/we needed to find a male Austin descendant of Archibald Sr. through his son Archibald, Jr., brother of Clisbe Sr. I/we discovered John Ellison by plain luck in Hamblen Co. TN.

John E.7Austin (Woodrow6, Jacob5???, William4, Arch Jr.3, Arch Sr.2, Edward Riggs1)… this was the 1st attempt to get at Arch Sr. as the MRCA. This test backfired! John Ellison Austin had no Austin Y-DNA and no Riggs Y-DNA. I now suspect John’s break in the Riggs Y-DNA chain at Jacob who is probably not a son of William but rather of William’s daughter Sara and a man with the likely name of Stultz. But this is another story in itself which I’m also working on.

This led me/us to you with some help from John Ellison.
Here is your connection which probably by-passes the problem with John Ellison Austin.  But I could be wrong.

Clay7 Austin (Joseph C. Jr.6, Joseph C Sr.5, William4, Archibald Jr.3, Arch Sr.2 Austin, Edward Riggs1).  
Your MRCA with Robert, Clyde, and William Luther Austin is Arch Sr. If you match these other three men, then the proof of Riggs Y-DNA will be taken all the way back to Arch Sr. Then what?

There is a large Riggs Y-DNA study also in progress. And below is Horace Riggs  whose Y-DNA is very close to that of Robert, Clyde and William Luther.  It varies by one marker mutation, which is quite possibly a “perfect” match since these bothersome mutation do occur, though only every 5-6 generations or so. 

Horace Lester7 Riggs III (Horace Lester6, Horace Lester5, John Woodson4, Samuel3, Clisbe2 Riggs, Edward Riggs1)
If Horace, whom I am in contact with, matches you, and since he shares a MRCA with you (and Robert, Clyde, and William Luther) of Edward Riggs (probably), then I/we will be very close to a proof that your ancestor is Edward Riggs (1720-1820). If the mutation that I talked about above can be explained through your Y-DNA, then the proof will be perfect.  I suspect that the mutation took place in Archibald Sr. Your Y-DNA can prove that to be true.
Hope this is understandable.
I appreciate your willingness to think about adding your Y-DNA to this study.
Of course if you would participate, I would cover the cost and would have the Y-DNA kit delivered to your home directly from Family Tree, Inc. Results would be available in 6-8 weeks.
Please consider participation.
John Clinard
Loudon TN, 865-607-9191
I’ll mail the CD to you on Monday.